Creamy Yogurt Cake

This super easy yogurt cake turns basic ingredients into a custardy, smooth dessert. Unlike regular cakes loaded with flour, butter and sugar, this lighter take uses Greek yogurt as its main ingredient, giving you more protein and way fewer calories. The cool part is how just a few everyday items change into something that feels like cheesecake inside with a slightly chewy outside. It's perfect if you want something sweet that won't mess up your healthy eating - you can throw it together in minutes and pop it in your air fryer or regular oven for a tasty treat.

I came up with this recipe during a midnight snack hunt when I wanted something sweet but my cupboards were pretty empty. After playing around with measurements, I couldn't believe that just yogurt, eggs and a bit of cornstarch made such an awesome dessert. My husband usually goes for traditional sweets and wasn't sure about it until he tried his first bite. He instantly asked if I'd used cream cheese, shocked by how rich and creamy it tasted with such basic stuff. Now we make it whenever we want a sweet treat without the heaviness of regular cake.

Basic Components

• 2 cups sweetened Greek yogurt: Makes up the smooth foundation with gentle sweetness; vanilla works best
• 3 large eggs: Gives the cake its form and helps it set while adding extra protein
• 2 tablespoons cornstarch: Soaks up extra moisture from yogurt to get the texture just right

The Greek yogurt you pick really changes how your cake turns out. I think sweetened, nonfat vanilla Greek yogurt works best for balanced flavor and creaminess. The yogurt does double duty as the main ingredient and the sweetener, so don't use plain unsweetened unless you'll add your own sugar. You can use regular yogurt instead, but it has more water so your cake will be firmer and less creamy. The cornstarch might seem weird, but it's key for soaking up extra moisture without making your cake heavy or changing the taste.

Quick Steps

Getting Ready:

Start with everything at room temp for the best results. Take your Greek yogurt and eggs out of the fridge about 30 minutes before you start cooking. Warm eggs mix into yogurt much better, so you won't get streaks in your batter. Measure out 2 cups of Greek yogurt carefully using a dry measuring cup. Use a knife to level it off for the most accurate amount. Get a 6-inch cake pan ready by either lining it with parchment or spraying it really well with cooking spray. If you're using an air fryer, make sure your pan fits in the basket with at least half an inch of space all around for good air flow.

Making Your Batter:

In a medium bowl, put in your 2 cups of sweetened Greek yogurt. Add the 3 eggs one at a time, whisking really well after each one until they're completely mixed in. The mixture should get lighter and a bit more liquid as you add each egg. Pay extra attention here because any egg that isn't mixed in well will make your cake uneven. Once all eggs are mixed in, sift your 2 tablespoons of cornstarch over the top to avoid lumps. Whisk hard until all the cornstarch dissolves and you can't see any white streaks. Your batter should look smooth and evenly mixed, kind of like thick pancake batter. Keep whisking for about a minute after all visible lumps are gone just to make sure the cornstarch is fully mixed in.

Getting Your Pan Ready:

Pour your batter into your lined or greased baking pan, but don't fill it more than three-quarters full because it'll puff up during cooking. The cake rises quite a bit while baking but settles down as it cools. Tap the pan gently against the counter a few times to get rid of air bubbles that might leave holes in your finished cake. Use a spatula to smooth the top of the batter for even cooking. For air fryer cooking, double-check that your pan fits without touching the sides or top of the air fryer. If you're using an oven, you might want to put the cake pan in a bigger dish with hot water that comes halfway up the sides of your cake pan - this helps keep the temperature steady and stops the cake from drying out during the longer baking time.

Air Fryer Cooking:

Warm up your air fryer to 300°F (150°C) for about 3 minutes. Put your cake pan in the basket carefully so you don't spill or tilt the batter. Cook for about 20-25 minutes total, but check it at 15 minutes by lightly touching the center - it should feel mostly set but still have a slight jiggle in the very middle. The top will naturally turn a nice golden brown. Air fryer cakes usually brown more evenly and don't sink as much when cooling, so they look prettier. When it's done cooking, turn off the air fryer but leave the cake inside with the drawer slightly open for about 5 minutes. This gradual cooling helps prevent the cake from shrinking too much or getting rubbery. After that rest time, take it out and let it cool completely on a wire rack before putting it in the fridge for at least two hours, which helps the flavors develop and the texture set properly.

Oven Cooking:

If you're using a regular oven, heat it to 325°F (165°C). Put your cake pan on the middle rack, preferably in a water bath as mentioned earlier. Bake for about 60-70 minutes, though time might vary depending on your oven and pan size. The cake is done when the edges are set and pulling slightly away from the pan, but the center still jiggles a little when gently shaken. Don't open the oven during the first 45 minutes of baking because temperature changes can make the cake sink dramatically. When it's done, turn off the oven but leave the cake inside with the door cracked open for about 15-20 minutes. This slow cooling helps prevent the top from wrinkling too much as it settles. After this initial cooling, take it out and let it finish cooling at room temperature before putting it in the fridge for at least 4 hours or overnight. Oven-baked cakes usually turn out moister than air fryer versions and tend to sink a bit more when cooled.

The first time I made this for my friends, I was worried what they'd think of such a basic dessert. They were totally amazed by how silky it was and kept asking what my "secret ingredient" was. When I told them it was mostly just Greek yogurt, nobody believed me until I showed them how I made it. What I really love about this cake is how it fixes my sweet cravings without making me feel heavy or guilty like regular desserts do. It's now my favorite afternoon snack with coffee since it gives me some protein and calcium while still feeling like a treat.

Tasty Twists

Take this simple recipe up a notch with add-ins that work well with its creamy nature. For a fruity version, gently mix in 1/2 cup of fresh blueberries or raspberries right before baking to create juicy pops of fruit throughout. Coffee lovers can add 1 teaspoon of espresso powder to the mix, which deepens the flavor and brings out the yogurt's natural sweetness. For something more indulgent, scatter 2 tablespoons of mini chocolate chips on top before cooking to create little pockets of melted chocolate that taste amazing against the creamy cake. If you like warm spices, mix in 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon or cardamom to give your basic cake a more grown-up taste. Citrus fans might enjoy adding 1 teaspoon of lemon or orange zest to brighten things up and balance the creaminess with a fresh zing.

Pin it

Sugar Tweaks

Adjust how sweet this cake is to match what you like without wrecking its texture. If you want it sweeter, stir in 2-3 tablespoons of regular sugar, honey, or maple syrup while mixing. When using honey or maple syrup, cut back to 1-2 tablespoons so you don't add too much liquid. For a healthier option, try 1-2 tablespoons of powdered erythritol or monk fruit sweetener, which add sweetness without all the calories of regular sugar. When serving, you can make a quick fruit sauce by cooking 1 cup of mixed berries with 1 tablespoon of sugar until it gets syrupy, then let it cool before spooning it over cake slices. A light sprinkle of powdered sugar just before serving looks pretty and adds a touch of sweetness to the top without overpowering the cake's gentle flavor. For special times, drizzle slices with a tablespoon of warmed honey mixed with a tiny bit of sea salt for a simple but fancy touch with extra sweetness.

Ways To Serve

Make this simple cake look impressive with thoughtful presentation and tasty sides. For morning meals, serve cold slices with fresh seasonal fruits that look pretty next to the cake while adding natural sweetness and different textures. For a fancy dessert, top each piece with a spoonful of lightly sweetened whipped cream and some toasted sliced almonds to add different textures and flavors. This cake's mild sweetness goes perfectly with strong coffee or spicy chai tea, making it great for afternoon get-togethers. For dinner parties, create pretty dessert plates by putting small wedges of cake next to colorful fruit sauces and fresh mint, using the sauce to make designs on the plate. Health-conscious folks might like the cake topped with extra Greek yogurt mixed with a bit of honey and cinnamon, which adds more yogurt flavor and gives each bite a creamy contrast.

Keeping It Fresh

Get the most from your yogurt cake by storing it right to keep its delicate texture and taste. For a few days, keep the fully cooled cake covered in the fridge, where it stays good for up to 3 days. The cake actually tastes better after the first day as the flavors blend and the texture firms up. When you're ready to eat refrigerated cake, let slices sit out for 10-15 minutes first so they warm up slightly and get that creamy feel back. If you want to keep it longer, wrap individual slices carefully in plastic wrap and then foil before freezing for up to a month. Thaw frozen pieces overnight in the fridge rather than on the counter to maintain the cake's structure. Don't leave this cake out at room temperature for long because of its high protein content - put leftovers back in the fridge after serving. If you see any liquid on the cake after storage, just gently dab it with a paper towel before serving to keep it looking nice.

Pin it

This yogurt cake has become my go-to for last-minute visitors and when I want a smarter dessert choice. What started as making do with what I had has turned into a recipe I use all the time. There's something really satisfying about making such a nice dessert with so little effort and such basic ingredients. I still find it kind of magical how it changes from simple batter into a creamy, custard-like cake. I especially love making it for friends who are watching what they eat - they're always happy to find a dessert that hits the spot without ruining their healthy plans.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I switch Greek yogurt for regular yogurt here?

Greek yogurt works best because it’s thicker and has more protein, giving the cake structure. Regular yogurt is watery and might make the cake too soft. You can strain regular yogurt overnight using cheesecloth in the fridge to get a Greek yogurt-like texture. Strain extra, though, since some volume will be lost.

→ What if I don’t have cornstarch?

Arrowroot powder works just like cornstarch, so that’s a great swap. You can also use all-purpose flour, but you’ll need double the amount (8 tablespoons instead of 4). Gluten-free options include potato starch or tapioca starch in a 1:1 swap for cornstarch. Each option may slightly tweak the texture.

→ Why does the cake sink after baking?

A little sinking is normal since the cake rises as it bakes and settles while cooling. But if it’s caving too much, it might’ve been underbaked, mixed too much, or the oven door was opened early. Let the cake bake fully until the center is set, avoid opening the door too soon, and mix ingredients gently.

→ Can I make this with flavored yogurt?

Go ahead! Flavored yogurts like lemon, strawberry, or blueberry can give a fun twist. Just note that they may already include extra sugar, so you might not need to sweeten the mix further. Baking times might change a little, though, since moisture can vary by flavor.

→ How do I know when this cake is ready to pull out?

It’s done when it’s puffed up, the surface has a caramel touch, and the center is no longer liquid when you shake it. In an air fryer, 320°F for about 20-23 minutes works. In the oven, try 350°F for 70-75 minutes. A toothpick should mostly come out clean. Chill for two hours before slicing for best texture!