Butterscotch Cheesecake Crumble

This velvety butterscotch cheesecake turns regular get-togethers into special events with its smooth filling and crunchy topping combo. The scratch-made butterscotch brings a cozy feeling that makes this treat stand out from regular cheesecakes, giving you different textures and tastes in every mouthful.

I whipped up this cheesecake for my sister's birthday after she asked for something "not ordinary but not too out there." Now our family wants it at practically every holiday dinner we have.

Ingredients

For the Crust

• Graham cracker crumbs: They form the trusty base with a hint of honey flavor
• Unsalted butter: Holds everything together and adds richness; try the European kind for better taste
• Granulated sugar: Cuts the salty taste and helps the crust turn golden when it bakes
• Salt: Brings out all other flavors; kosher works best for even spreading

For the Cheesecake Filling

• Cream cheese: Makes our smooth base; go for full fat and let it soften for the best results
• Light brown sugar: Gives richer flavor than plain white sugar with tiny hints of molasses
• Large eggs: Add body and richness; take them out early so they're not cold
• Vanilla extract: Brings lovely background flavor; worth buying the good stuff here
• Heavy cream: Creates that dreamy smooth feel; regular pasteurized works better than ultra
• Butterscotch chips: They melt into sweet caramel pockets throughout

For the Buttery Crumble Topping

• All purpose flour: Gives the crumble its structure
• Light brown sugar: Turns golden and sweet while baking
• Cold unsalted butter: Makes those tasty crumbly bits we love
• Salt: Balances the sweetness; you can't skip this

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Crust

Combine:

Mix graham cracker crumbs with melted butter, sugar, and salt until all crumbs look wet for good sticking power. Push firmly into your springform pan with a measuring cup's flat bottom to make an even, tight layer. This stops your crust from falling apart when served. Just bake until you smell it and it looks slightly golden – this makes a barrier that keeps filling from making it soggy.

Create the Cheesecake Filling

Beat:

Whip cream cheese by itself until it's totally smooth like thick frosting with zero lumps at all. Mix in brown sugar completely until the mix gets lighter in color and texture, showing it's got enough air. Put in eggs one at a time, letting each mix in fully before adding another, which stops over-mixing that can cause cracks. Gently fold in heavy cream to keep the air bubbles that make it light. Stir in melted butterscotch chips while they're still warm but not hot so they spread evenly through the batter.

Craft the Buttery Crumble

Work:

Fast with cold stuff to get those perfect butter chunks that make this cheesecake extra good. Stir dry things first so salt and sugar spread out evenly. Cut butter into tiny squares, then rub into flour mix with your fingers until you get different sized bits from small peas to bigger chunks. This mix of sizes makes every bite interesting. Cool it down briefly if it gets too warm from your hands.

Bake with Care

Place:

Your pan on a baking sheet to catch any butter that might leak out. Bake until the middle wobbles just a little bit, like jello that's almost set, while the edges look firmer. The crumble should look golden caramel colored without burning. Don't ever open the oven in the first 40 minutes of baking, as this can make the temperature drop too fast and cause cracks. Let it cool slowly in the turned-off oven, which stops the quick temperature change that makes cheesecakes crack.

Perfect the Chill

Refrigerate:

Without covering for the first hour, then loosely put foil on top for the rest of the time. This stops water drops from falling onto your pretty crumble topping. Try to let it chill overnight whenever you can, since the flavors get so much better during this time.

Pin it

Those butterscotch chips really make this dessert shine. After lots of testing, I found that melting them before mixing them in gives you smooth flavor throughout instead of super sweet spots here and there. My mother-in-law always said she didn't like butterscotch until she tried this cheesecake – it completely changed her mind!

Getting That Dreamy Texture

The key to that amazing creamy texture is taking your time. Let all dairy stuff sit out for about two hours to reach room temperature before starting. This helps everything mix properly and stops those tiny lumps that mess up homemade cheesecakes. Also, beating just the cream cheese first before adding anything else creates the smooth base that makes this dessert so amazing.

Stopping Cracks From Forming

While the crumble top nicely hides any flaws, you can get a perfectly smooth cheesecake by using a water bath. Just wrap your springform pan in several layers of strong foil, going all the way up the sides, then put it in a bigger pan filled with hot water halfway up the cheesecake pan. This gentle, moist heat stops quick temperature changes that cause cracks. Cooling slowly in the turned-off oven also helps keep your cheesecake looking great.

Serving Suggestions

This butterscotch treat tastes wonderful with a little warm salted caramel sauce drizzled over top for extra yumminess. For something refreshing on the side, add lightly whipped cream with just a touch of brown sugar and vanilla. In fall, try sprinkling some cinnamon into the whipped cream for seasonal flavor. For a wow-factor presentation, warm up a few spoonfuls of butterscotch chips with a spoonful of heavy cream to make a pourable sauce, then drizzle over each slice just before bringing to the table.

Make It Your Own

You can easily change this recipe to suit your taste. Maybe add a pinch of cinnamon to the crust for a warm flavor. Mix some chopped toasted pecans into the crumble for a nice crunch. If you love chocolate, swirl in some melted dark chocolate right before baking. During summer, a spoonful of bourbon in the filling adds grown-up flavor that goes great with the butterscotch. The basic recipe works well for trying new ideas while still tasting amazing.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I swap out the crust for something else?

Absolutely! You can try using crushed Oreos, digestive cookies, or a shortbread crust instead of the graham cracker base for a new taste.

→ What’s the safest way to melt butterscotch chips?

Place the chips in a microwave-safe bowl, heat in 15-second bursts, and stir till they’re completely melted and smooth.

→ How do I make the filling lump-free?

Let the cream cheese come to room temperature, then beat it well with the sugar before mixing in the other ingredients for a silky filling.

→ Can this dessert be made ahead?

Yes! It tastes even better when prepared the day before. Let it chill overnight for the most delicious results.

→ What’s the trick to a crunchy crumble topping?

Use cold butter and mix it until the crumbs form a coarse texture. Sprinkle evenly for that perfect crispiness.