Pin it
Sometimes you just need something cozy and this BBQ Chicken Mac and Cheese totally nails those cravings. It mixes up smoky, cheesy magic and is perfect when you want something filling but super easy. I reach for this one midweek when everyone's hungry and time is tight—nobody ever says no at dinner.
The first time I tried making this was one hectic Sunday night. Now, whenever we have leftover chicken or there’s some cheddar in the fridge, my family insists on it. My kids always come back for more and it’s a breeze to double if you're planning ahead for lunches.
Easy Ingredients
- Fresh chopped parsley: Chopped green herb for a little bright flavor Totally optional but looks nice on top
- Salt and pepper: Basic must-have for flavor Taste as you mix and add as you like
- Smoked paprika: Adds a soft smoky flavor Spanish types have the real deal smokiness
- Onion powder: Brings mellow, savory vibes Buy a small jar so it’s always fresh
- Garlic powder: Little bit of extra depth in every bite Just be sure yours smells strong and fragrant
- BBQ sauce: Big, bold, smoky flavor Pick your favorite with real smoke if possible
- Milk: Helps everything get smooth and creamy I like to use low-fat for a lighter taste
- Shredded mozzarella cheese: This one makes it stretchy and melty Look for low moisture for best pull
- Shredded cheddar cheese: The punchy cheese flavor Buy a block and shred your own for creamier melt
- Elbow macaroni or your favorite pasta: Catches the sauce in every nook Go for pasta with ridges if you want extra sauce action
- Olive oil: Keeps the chicken juicy and adds some good flavor Extra-virgin is the move here
- Cooked and shredded chicken breast: Tender bits of chicken cooked just right Ask your butcher for thick pieces for easier shredding
Simple How-To Steps
- Garnish and Dig In:
- Add some chopped parsley for a fresh look and taste if you want. Spoon into bowls and dive right in. Taste and toss in a little more salt and pepper if it needs a flavor boost.
- Mix in the Barbecue Chicken:
- Stir the BBQ-coated chicken into your super creamy pasta. Mix everything so every spoonful gets some chicken and sauce. Let it heat up for another minute to blend those flavors together.
- Get Pasta Ready:
- Start by cooking your macaroni or the pasta you picked in salted water until it’s just barely softened. Drain it well and leave it out so it won’t get soggy in the sauce.
- Cheese Sauce Time:
- Pour milk into a separate pan and warm it on medium heat. Gradually drop in cheddar then mozzarella, stirring non-stop until the sauce is totally smooth. Don’t rush or your cheese might clump up.
- Flavor Boost the Chicken:
- Sprinkle on barbecue sauce, smoked paprika, onion powder, garlic powder, salt, and pepper. Gently stir so every bit of chicken gets coated and shiny. Let it sit for another minute to absorb the flavors.
- Blend Noodles with Cheese:
- Add your cooked, drained macaroni into the cheesy sauce. Give it a good stir until all the pasta's covered and glossy.
- Heat the Chicken:
- Bump a skillet to medium with a little olive oil. Warm up the shredded chicken just a few minutes, stir carefully so it stays tender.
Pin it
My littlest always loves to help out by mixing up the cheese sauce and the scent of smoked paprika just takes me straight back to warm summer cookouts with everyone coming together and doing their own version of comfort food.
Smart Storage Ideas
Let your leftovers totally cool before stashing so your pasta doesn’t get soft. Scoop them into airtight boxes then pop in the fridge for three days max. Sauce too thick after chilling? Just splash in a bit of milk before reheating and it’ll be good as new. Don’t keep parsley on top—it just goes limp.
Swap Options
If you’re out of chicken, shredded cooked turkey tastes great too and don’t stress about the pasta shape—anything with little spaces for sauce will work. Try Monterey Jack cheese for a mild twist or even smoked gouda if you want more flavor. Using dairy-free? Most lactose-free milk or cheese brands will work just fine here.
Serving Ideas
Want to get fancy? Sprinkle on some crispy bacon or stir in cooked peas for a pop of color and easy veggies. Goes great next to a crisp salad or simple coleslaw if you need something fresh. Serve it out of the big pot for parties or portion into small dishes when kids have friends over for dinner.
Pin it
Quick Food History
This awesome mix joins up two long-time classics—mac and cheese goes way back, and barbecue chicken brings those American smokehouse vibes home. It proves hearty family meals can always change and keep getting better, bite after bite.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is it okay to pick a different pasta?
Yep! You don’t have to use elbows—shells, penne, or any small pasta shapes will catch the cheesy goodness too.
- → Can I throw in rotisserie chicken?
Go for it—rotisserie chicken makes this even quicker. Just tear it up, toss with BBQ sauce, and you’re set.
- → Any other cheese options work here?
Definitely. Try swapping in Monterey Jack, Colby, or even Gouda if you want to mix things up.
- → How do I give it a spicy kick?
Chop in some jalapeños or just sprinkle in a little cayenne when you stir everything together.
- → What’s the best way to keep leftovers fresh?
Spoon it into a sealed container, stash it in the fridge, and eat it within three days. Warm up with a splash of milk to keep it creamy.
- → Can I sneak in some veggies?
Sautéed onions, bell pepper, or a handful of peas will blend right in and make it even better.