Herby Ranch Mashed Potatoes

Comfort food doesn’t get any cozier than these ranch-style mashed potatoes. They’re fluffy and creamy, loaded with garden-fresh herbs and a little tangy kick from buttermilk. You’ll find they’re super easy to make for any occasion—from weeknight family dinners to holiday spreads. The first time my family tried them at Thanksgiving, they didn’t leave a spoonful behind. Now we make these all the time.

I used to skip the dill, thinking it was extra, but now it’s the best part! The kids love that little hit of green and always ask for more.

Delicious Ingredients

• Chopped chives, parsley, and dill: Pick bunches that look super fresh, chop ‘em up right before using for big flavor and color
• Cream cheese: You want the plain kind, full-fat. Let it sit out to warm up—it’ll blend right in and make things extra silky
• Unsalted butter: Go with a good brand; it adds so much richness
• Fine sea salt and cracked black pepper: Season as you go and don’t be shy—it really brings all the flavors forward
• Large garlic cloves: Mince up some fresh ones for a cozy, savory taste
• Buttermilk: Whole buttermilk gives that tangy ranch vibe. Warm it gently first so everything mixes smoothly
• Russet potatoes: They soak up all that goodness and make the mash nice and light
• Yukon Gold potatoes: Adds a creamy, buttery texture and you can leave the peels for more texture if you like

Easy Steps

Dish Up:

Scoop your gorgeously fluffy mash into a warm bowl. Toss on extra herbs if you feel fancy and bring it straight to the table.

Final Taste:

Give it one last taste for salt and pepper. This last round makes all the difference.

Mix Cream Cheese:

Drop in the cream cheese and gently fold until it's just blended in. If it feels a little thick, splash in more warmed buttermilk. You want it dreamy, not dry!

Add Herby Butter:

Pour your butter-buttermilk-herb mix into the potatoes bit by bit. Stir slowly to keep the mash super fluffy.

Mash Potatoes:

Grab your masher or ricer. Don’t go wild—just mash till you hit your favorite texture.

Let Steam Off:

Once you’ve drained the water, throw them back into the hot pot. Let them hang out over low heat, shaking gently for a minute. That extra steam leaving will help keep things light.

Warm the Mix-ins:

While the potatoes cook, slowly warm together butter, buttermilk, salt, and pepper. Don’t let it boil—just blend. Stir in the fresh herbs so they stay bright.

Simmer Potatoes:

Pour in enough water to cover everything, salt, drop in garlic, and bring to a strong boil. Lower the heat to a gentle bubble, cook till potatoes are fork-tender (ten to twelve minutes), then drain fast.

Chop Spuds:

Slice your potatoes into chunks about an inch big so they cook evenly. Peel if you want them extra smooth, or keep peels for rustic feel. Toss into a large pot, cover with cold water.

Pin it

Honestly, I get the biggest kick from stirring in the herbs at the end. They make the whole bowl look gorgeous and the kitchen smells like fresh greens. My kids jump in to help chop and always get a kick out of it—it’s our little tradition.

Keeping It Fresh

Pop leftovers into an airtight box and stash in the fridge for three days tops. To bring back that creamy-good texture, reheat slowly with a splash of buttermilk or regular milk. Want to save longer Freeze them in little zip bags, though they’ll be just a tad softer after thawing.

Swaps and Fixes

No buttermilk No sweat. Squeeze a little lemon into milk and wait a few minutes—it’ll do the trick. Sour cream works too. For a dairy-free spin, swap in creamy plant milk and vegan butter, and throw in extra herbs for flavor. Don’t sweat missing herbs—use what’s in your fridge or add a sprinkle of dried ones.

What to Pair With

Spoon these fluffy mashed potatoes under some warm gravy or just dust with more chives. Awesome next to roast chicken, meatloaf, or pot roast. Got leftovers Fry up patties the next morning for killer potato cakes!

Pin it

Fun Background

The ranchy flavor comes from a mix of buttermilk, herbs, and zippy seasoning—straight from ranch’s Western roots. Mixing it into mashed potatoes makes something old-school but brand new at the same time. It tastes super familiar but there’s an exciting twist.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make this dish ahead of time?

Definitely, fix these mashed potatoes early and gently warm them on the stove when you'd like. Drizzle in some extra buttermilk if they need a little more creaminess.

→ How do I prevent gummy mashed potatoes?

Let your potatoes dry in the pan after boiling and fold in your wet ingredients gently. Try not to over-mix so they stay light and fluffy.

→ Is it necessary to peel the potatoes?

Nope, peeling’s up to you. Leave skins on for more bites of texture and nutrients, or peel for a silkier finish.

→ Can I use only one type of potato?

Of course! Stick with either Yukon Gold or russets if you'd like. Using both just kicks up the texture and taste a bit more.

→ What herbs work best for this dish?

Chives, parsley, and dill give you that ranch vibe. If all you’ve got is dried, toss in a little less to keep the flavors balanced.