Pin it
This Meat Lovers Pizza Casserole takes all those tasty pizza parts—loads of meats, gooey cheese, and saucy goodness—and turns them into a hearty dish you can scoop up with a spoon. It’s crazy easy to toss together and always disappears fast, which makes it my go-to when there’s a hungry crowd or just a lazy Saturday at home. Every spoonful is packed with flavor, chewy bites, and melty cheese—no wonder it’s a family favorite around here.
The first time I served this was after a ball game and my kids were already after seconds before I sat down. These days, it’s my lifesaver for cozy nights and everybody always cleans their plate.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Red pepper flakes: totally up to you, but bring a nice kick—get them fresh for best zing
- Garlic powder: gives a tasty boost—granulated kinds sprinkle more even
- Grated Parmesan cheese: nutty and tangy—if you’re up for it, grate your own right before baking
- Shredded cheddar cheese: sharp, bold flavor—go extra sharp when you want that punch
- Shredded mozzarella cheese: stretches and melts like pizza—buy a block and shred so it’s extra gooey
- Italian seasoning: brings that classic pizzeria smell—look for a blend heavy on oregano, basil, and thyme
- Marinara or pizza sauce: it’s the sauce that makes all the magic—grab one that’s thick and packed with real tomatoes
- Cooked and crumbled bacon: smoky and crispy—thick-cut gives you meaty bites
- Pepperoni slices: for that spicy pop—uncured or low-salt versions taste fresh
- Italian sausage: all about depth and a little heat—get it from the butcher for best taste
- Ground beef: heartiness in every bite—go for freshly ground if possible for that bit of bite
- Pasta: penne or rotini catch all the sauce—bronze-cut holds sauce better so nothing’s bland
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Rest and Dish Up:
- Let the casserole chill out from the oven for five minutes so it’s easier to slice. Dish it up while hot and melty—you’ll get those perfect cheesy pulls every time.
- Bake Until Golden:
- Pop your dish into a hot oven at three seventy-five degrees. Bake twenty to twenty-five minutes or until it’s bubbling and golden. Want the top crispy? Switch to broil for a minute or two, just don’t let it burn.
- Toss on More Cheese:
- Cover every inch with shredded mozzarella, sprinkle on sharp cheddar, and finish with a bunch of Parmesan for that epic crust.
- Layer in the Dish:
- Coat a 9x13 pan with butter or spray. Scoop your pasta mix in and spread it all the way out so it bakes even.
- Mix the Middle:
- Grab a giant bowl. Add cooked pasta, all your browned meat, bacon, pepperoni, thick sauce, Italian herbs, garlic, and optional chili flakes. Stir super well so every scoop picks up all the flavors.
- Sizzle the Meats:
- Get your skillet hot and toss in the sausage and ground beef. Keep breaking it up with your spoon until no pink is left. Drain out all the fat so nothing’s greasy.
- Pasta Ready:
- Boil pasta in salty water, just to al dente (still a little firm). Drain, splash with oil to keep it from clumping, and set it aside.
Pin it
Honestly, the spicy edges on the pepperoni make this dish irresistible for me—the way it crisps up can’t be beat. One time we made this while watching a movie and never bothered with plates. Straight from the pan was the way to go.
Storage Tips
Once cooled, toss extra pieces in airtight tubs and stick them in the fridge—they’ll be fine for up to three days. For freezing, wrap portions tightly with as little air inside as possible, and stash in the freezer up to two months. Want to reheat? Oven at three fifty until hot or quick blasts in the microwave when you don’t want to wait.
Ingredient Swaps
Use ground turkey for something leaner, or try those veggie burger crumbles if you want to go meatless. Gluten-free pasta works just as well—chickpea or rice ones are both good with sauce and cheese. Toss in mushrooms, peppers, or a handful of spinach for more veggies too.
Pin it
Serving Ideas
This goes great with a crunchy green salad and vinaigrette for something fresh. Warm breadsticks or soft rolls are perfect for soaking up all that sauce. Want to make it special? Put out little dishes of grated cheese and chili flakes and let everyone top their portion.
Cultural Backstory
This dish celebrates how folks took the love of pizza and squeezed it into homey casseroles. It took off in America as a one-pan answer for busy weekdays and big family get-togethers. It’s all pizza flavor but baked up cozy—totally nostalgic and always hits the spot.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I add vegetables for more flavor?
You bet! Toss in mushrooms, peppers, or some onion to the pasta mix before baking for more crunch and flavor.
- → How should leftovers be stored and reheated?
Pop leftovers in the fridge with a cover for up to three days, or freeze it in portions. Heat it up in the microwave or oven until nice and hot.
- → Is it possible to make this casserole gluten-free?
Just use gluten-free pasta, and double-check your meats and sauces are gluten-free too. Tastes just as good!
- → How do I achieve a crispy cheese top?
Flip on your broiler when the casserole's done baking and let it go for two to three minutes. Watch it like a hawk so it gets that golden brown but doesn't char.
- → Can I substitute meats in the dish?
Go ahead and switch things up. Turkey works where beef is, and smoked chicken sausage is fun too—just cook your meats all the way first.
- → What type of pasta works best for this?
Penne and rotini noodles both do great. They grab the sauce and cheese and bake up nice and even.