Pin it
Whenever I want a touch of southern flair at dinner, this red snapper with creamy Creole sauce totally hits the spot. The fish stays delicate and juicy underneath a crisp golden exterior, while that creamy sauce packs a punch with big, bold Louisiana flavors. Scoop everything over a pile of rice or use warm bread to catch every drop and it's a sure way to kick up an ordinary night.
I cooked up this snapper for the first time because I was craving New Orleans meals but wasn't in the mood for a packed restaurant. The quick Creole sauce blew me away—it became a staple at my house right after that.
Easy Ingredients
- Fresh red snapper fillets: have a mild sweetness and keep their shape even in sauce. Look for clear flesh with a light scent and a bit of firmness
- Extra virgin olive oil: brings flavor and helps get a great sear. Go for high quality if you can
- Black pepper and salt: add the basics so the rest of the tastes shine
- Paprika: turns everything a rich color and brings gentle earthiness. Try smoky Spanish paprika for something special
- Garlic powder: super easy and adds a nice savory layer to the fish
- Quality unsalted butter: melts down smooth and starts the sauce right. The better the butter, the richer the result
- Bell pepper and onion: these veggies become the sauce’s base. Choose fresh, heavy, glossy ones for best flavor
- Firm fresh garlic cloves: throw lots of kick into the sauce’s aroma
- Creole seasoning blend: tosses in that bold Louisiana taste with plenty of zip and less salt if you use homemade
- A dash of cayenne: just go easy and add more if you love things spicy
- Full-fat heavy cream: brings melt-in-your-mouth richness. Pick one with as few ingredients as you can
- Chicken broth (homemade or low salt): makes the sauce deep and savory
- Diced tomatoes (if you want): pop them in for a fresh hit or use good canned ones if tomatoes are out of season
- Flat leaf fresh parsley: scattered on top at the end for a green boost and bright taste
Simple Steps
- Top It All Off:
- At the end, sprinkle chopped parsley across your snapper and serve with the sides you love most—soak up that sauce!
- Bring Fish and Sauce Together:
- Slide the snapper pieces back into the pan of sauce and spoon a bit over each. Let it all get warm for a minute or two.
- Wrap Up the Sauce:
- Pour in the heavy cream and lower the heat so things barely bubble. Let it simmer for five minutes until the sauce gets a little thicker and creamy.
- Add Broth and Tomatoes:
- Toss in the chicken broth and diced tomatoes (if you want them), scrape up any tasty bits from the skillet, and simmer for a couple of minutes so everything melds.
- Spice It Up:
- Mix in minced garlic, your Creole seasoning, plus a pinch of cayenne. Stir for about sixty seconds until it starts to smell irresistible (just don’t let the garlic burn).
- Sauté the Veggies:
- With the pan dropping to medium heat, melt the butter, then add chopped onion and bell pepper. Keep stirring for four to five minutes till soft and the kitchen smells amazing.
- Cook the Snapper:
- Heat olive oil in a big skillet on medium-high. Carefully lay the seasoned fillets in and let them cook about three to four minutes per side—look for a bold golden crust and flaky inside. Move fish off the heat and keep it ready.
- Prep the Fish:
- Dry off your snapper fillets using paper towels so they’ll brown nicely. Season both sides with pepper, salt, paprika, and garlic powder.
Pin it
When shopping, grab snapper with bright, shiny eyes and a clean, fresh smell. Whenever I bring this out, my crew gets excited and I’ll never forget the grin my dad gave me when I finally tried making Creole sauce at home.
Storing Your Meal
Let any leftovers cool down, then pack them into a tight-lidded container and stash in the fridge. They’ll stay good for up to two days. To reheat, warm fish and sauce together over low heat—this keeps the snapper juicy and the sauce nice and smooth.
Swap Options
No red snapper around? Go for tilapia, flounder, or grouper since they've got that same gentle flavor and texture. For a lighter sauce, swap in half and half instead of cream—it's a bit thinner but still rich. Want to mix up Creole spice yourself? Combine paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, and a shake of cayenne.
Serving Ideas
Try this with fluffy brown or jasmine rice for soaking up the sauce, or creamy mashed spuds for extra comfort. Crusty bread is a winner too. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, pair with bright sautéed green beans or roasted asparagus.
Pin it
Creole Story
Creole food brings together French, Spanish, West African, and Native American influences. It’s all about bold spices, aromatic veggies, and creamy, satisfying textures. Creole sauces usually start with a mix of bell peppers, onions, and tomatoes—they call this the holy trinity because it’s the flavor hero.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's a simple way to know my red snapper's done?
As soon as the fillet gets flaky and isn't see-through in the middle, it's good to go. Don't let it go too long or it'll dry out, so keep an eye on it right at the end.
- → How do I tweak the spice level for this sauce?
Craving more heat? Sprinkle in extra cayenne or Creole spice. Want it mild? Skip the cayenne and add just a little seasoning at a time—taste and adjust as you go.
- → What sides go great with it?
A pile of rice, a scoop of mashed potatoes, or a chunk of French bread are perfect for catching all that tasty Creole sauce.
- → If I can't get snapper, can I swap in other fish?
For sure! Cod, tilapia, or grouper do the trick if you need. Just watch your cooking time so the fish stays flaky and moist.
- → Need the Creole sauce thicker? What's the trick?
Just let it bubble without the lid for a while and stir now and then. It'll thicken up the longer it reduces.