Stuffed Avocado Caprese

This avocado Caprese combo turns basic items into a mouth-watering treat for all your senses. Half avocados work as natural cups, filled with bright cherry tomatoes, tiny fresh mozzarella balls, and fragrant basil pesto. Every mouthful gives you a perfect mix of smooth, sweet, zesty, and herby flavors that light up your taste buds. Top it off with some thick balsamic drizzle, and you've got a stunning flavor mix that makes simple stuff taste fancy in just minutes.

The first time I brought these filled avocados to a backyard party, they were gone in seconds. Even folks who said they weren't big on avocados couldn't stay away from the tempting mix of classic Caprese stuff tucked into that buttery avocado flesh. My husband's mom asked me right away how I made them, shocked that something so fancy-looking came together so fast. Now whenever I see perfectly ripe avocados at the store, I can't help but think about making this dish to show them off properly.

Quality Ingredients

• 2 large ripe avocados: Gives you that smooth texture and healthy oils; they should feel slightly soft when you press them
• 1 cup cherry tomatoes: Adds juicy pops of sweetness; grab different colors for extra eye appeal
• 1 cup fresh mozzarella pearls: Brings mild creaminess to the mix; make sure to drain them well
• 2 tablespoons basil pesto: Packs in herb flavor throughout; works with homemade or from the store
• 1 small garlic clove: Gives a mild flavor kick; chop it tiny so it spreads evenly

Finding just the right avocados makes all the difference in this dish. They need to give just a bit when you press gently but shouldn't feel mushy. I like Hass avocados best because they're so creamy and ripen in a predictable way. For tomatoes, the little grape or cherry ones are just the right size and have the perfect amount of juice. If you're making this when tomatoes aren't in season, look for the small greenhouse ones still on the vine – they usually taste better year-round than the big tomatoes do.

Easy Steps

Picking Your Avocados:

Start with avocados that feel slightly soft when squeezed. Slice them down the middle, working your knife around the seed. Twist the halves in opposite ways to split them open. Take out the seed by carefully hitting it with a knife then twisting, or just scoop it out with a spoon. Use your spoon to make the hole a bit bigger without breaking through the skin, giving you more room for your filling. This extra space lets you pack in more yummy Caprese mix while keeping the avocado from falling apart.

Making the Filling:

Clean your cherry tomatoes and dry them off before cutting them in half or quarters depending on how big they are. Smaller pieces soak up more pesto flavor and mix better with everything else. Drain your mozzarella pearls completely and pat them dry with paper towels to get rid of extra moisture that could water down the flavors. If you can only find bigger mozzarella balls, cut them into small pieces about the same size as your tomato chunks so every bite has a nice balance. The same sized pieces make sure you get a bit of everything in each mouthful.

Adding the Pesto:

In a bowl, mix your cut tomatoes and mozzarella balls. Pour in the basil pesto, starting with one tablespoon and adding more if you want a stronger basil taste. Chop the garlic very small and add it to the mix, stirring it through everything. The raw garlic gives a nice little kick that goes great with the sweet tomatoes and soft cheese. Gently fold everything together with a spatula instead of stirring hard, which can smash the delicate tomatoes and cheese. This careful mixing coats everything with the fragrant pesto while keeping each ingredient intact.

Putting It Together:

Spoon plenty of the Caprese mix into each avocado hole, letting it pile up a bit on top for a nice look. Press the filling gently into the avocado to get rid of air pockets without crushing everything. If you're serving right away, place the stuffed avocados on some fresh basil leaves, which looks great and adds extra smell as the leaves warm up from the avocados. For a steadier presentation, cut a thin slice off the bottom of each avocado half so they sit flat on the plate without wobbling. This small trick makes a big difference in how fancy they look.

Last Touches:

Right before serving, pour about a teaspoon of balsamic glaze over each stuffed avocado, letting it flow naturally across the filling and onto the avocado flesh. Use the back of your spoon to make pretty streaks of glaze on the plate if you want it to look restaurant-quality. For extra flavor and visual pop, sprinkle a little fancy sea salt and fresh black pepper on top. These final seasonings bring out all the flavors and add some texture. For special occasions, top with a sprinkle of fresh basil cut into thin strips as the final garnish, adding bright color and boosting the basil flavor from the pesto.

I've tried lots of different stuffed avocado recipes, but this Caprese version always gets the best reactions from my friends and family. Something about the cool, creamy avocado mixed with those classic Italian flavors of tomatoes, mozzarella and basil just works like magic together. What I really love is how the good fats in the avocado make this light dish actually fill you up, perfect for when you want something special that won't weigh you down.

Peak Freshness

Getting the best flavor in this simple dish mostly depends on using quality stuff and timing things right. For the best results, pick avocados that just turned ripe instead of ones that have been soft for days. The perfect avocado should feel the same all over when gently squeezed, without mushy spots. To stop browning if you're prepping a bit ahead of time, brush some lemon juice on the avocado flesh, which adds brightness and prevents that ugly brown color. When choosing mozzarella, the fresh little balls packed in water taste way better than the firmer vacuum-sealed kinds. For the prettiest presentation, mix the Caprese stuff no more than half an hour before serving so everything keeps its own texture while the flavors start to blend together.

Pin it

Serving Ideas

Change up this flexible dish to fit any occasion with smart serving choices and side items. For a fancy first course, set each stuffed avocado half on its own small plate with some peppery arugula underneath, creating an elegant look that lets guests enjoy the full visual impact. When serving as a main lunch dish, add some toasted crusty bread rubbed with garlic for a nice crunch and extra substance. For a bigger meal, pair with a light soup like cold cucumber or traditional gazpacho, whose tanginess balances out the rich avocado perfectly. During summer, these stuffed avocados look great at outdoor parties when placed in trays filled with ice that keep them cool and fresh throughout the event.

Mix It Up

Try some tasty twists on this flexible recipe by switching up ingredients and adding new elements. For a Mediterranean flavor, swap the regular pesto for olive tapenade and use crumbled feta instead of mozzarella, finished with good olive oil instead of balsamic glaze. Seafood lovers might enjoy adding some tiny cooked shrimp or crab meat to the Caprese mix, making a heartier protein-packed version perfect for dinner. Heat fans can kick things up by mixing in finely chopped jalapeño and using cilantro-lime pesto instead of the traditional basil kind. For a totally different taste, try a Greek version with diced cucumber, halved kalamata olives, and crumbled feta dressed with a simple lemon and olive oil mix and fresh dill instead of basil.

Storage Tips

Get the most from this fresh dish by knowing how to handle and store it for the best flavor. While it's tastiest right after you make it, you can prep some parts ahead for convenience. The Caprese filling mix can be combined up to a day ahead and kept in a sealed container in the fridge, though the tomatoes might release some juice over time. If prepping early, save a little fresh pesto to mix in just before serving to wake up the flavors. Always cut avocados as close to serving time as possible, but if needed, you can wrap halved avocados tightly with plastic wrap pressed against the cut surface and keep them in the fridge for up to 4 hours before filling. If you have leftovers, scoop the filling and avocado flesh from the skins, mix together in a sealed container with a squeeze of lemon juice, and refrigerate to use the next day as a spread or dip.

Pin it

I came up with this Caprese stuffed avocado during a really hot summer when I didn't want to turn on the stove. What started as just throwing together some favorite ingredients without cooking turned into one of my most requested dishes. The difference between the cool, buttery avocado and the bright, herby filling makes it feel both fancy and healthy at the same time. Though I've played around with many versions over the years, I always come back to this classic combo that shows off simple, good ingredients at their best.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What’s the best way to pick ripe avocados?

Find avocados that feel soft but not squishy when you give them a gentle press. Dark green to black skin tones are your friends. Peek under the tiny stem on top—if it’s simple to pull off and looks green inside, it’s ready. Struggle to remove it? It’s underripe. Brown underneath? It’s gone too far. Slightly firm avocados hold their shape best for stuffing.

→ Can I prep stuffed avocados ahead of time?

Eating this right after making it is ideal. But, you can prepare the filling up to a day early and store it in the fridge. To keep the cut avocado fresh, brush its surface with lemon juice. Keep them separate, then assemble and serve right before eating. Or for parties, set up a little 'make-your-own' station where guests stuff their own avocados.

→ Don’t have balsamic glaze? What can I use?

You can make your own glaze by warming balsamic vinegar in a pan until it thickens. No time for that? Mix some honey with a dash of balsamic vinegar, or just drizzle olive oil and squeeze a little lemon juice. You could also try pomegranate molasses or a mild fruit sauce for a unique flavor twist.

→ How do I make these more filling?

Add extra protein like seasoned chicken chunks, cooked shrimp, or some white beans to your filling. Pair the avocados with a hot soup, grains like quinoa, or crusty bread. You could even toss the ingredients with pasta or zucchini noodles for an easy salad-style entree.

→ What’s the trick to eating these neatly?

Scoop them straight from the shell with a spoon, going through the filling and avocado flesh for each bite. If serving at a dinner table, place them on a plate and use a knife and fork. Pro tip for parties: pre-slice the avocado inside before stuffing, so guests can scoop bite-sized portions effortlessly.